The short answer
Pick a catamaran for space, stability and value: most take 18 guests, two take 30, and 4 hours start from $2,090. Pick a motor yacht for speed, more size options and the very top end, from $1,395 on a Sea Ray 50 to the Hatteras 122. Prices are per yacht, in USD, with 10 guests included on most.
Catamaran or motor yacht: which should we book?
For most groups, the answer comes down to three questions: how many of you there are, how far you want to go, and how much you want to spend per person. Catamarans win on space, stability and value. Motor yachts win on speed, range of sizes and a sleeker look in photos. Both carry a captain and crew, and both include fuel within the bay, ice, purified water, soft drinks and snorkel gear.
Here is how the two compare across the fleet, with real prices from our yachts.
What is the actual difference?
A catamaran stands on two hulls joined by a wide deck. That gives you a broad, level platform: a cockpit table for lunch, a trampoline or sun pads on the bow, and room for a group to spread out. Most of our catamarans are sailing catamarans, which can raise their sails when the wind allows. The Leopard 51 is a power catamaran and runs on engines. Ask Kyle how the Pajot 47 is set up on your date.
A motor yacht has a single hull and runs on engines. Depending on the yacht you get a flybridge (an upper deck with a view), a saloon, a swim platform at the stern and, on the larger ones, extras like a jacuzzi or a waterslide. Our motor yachts run from express cruisers for small groups to the 122-foot Hatteras.
Which is more stable?
A catamaran, in most conditions. The two hulls sit far apart, so the boat rocks less at anchor and feels steadier underfoot. That is why families with young children, grandparents and anyone who worries about motion often pick one.
A motor yacht moves differently. Under way it can feel smooth and quick, and at anchor a single hull tends to move more with the swell. If someone in your group is nervous about seasickness, start with a catamaran and a morning charter, and bring any medication you use.
Which has more space?
For the same price, usually the catamaran. The wide deck gives you more usable outdoor space, and the cockpit table seats a whole group for lunch. Most of our catamarans take up to 18 guests; the La Cruz 47 takes 16, the VIP Lagoon 42 takes 20 and the Leopard 51 takes 30.
Motor yachts give you more choice at the top end. The Hatteras 75 takes up to 45 guests and the Cheoy Lee 90 up to 46, which no catamaran in the fleet matches. If your group is over 30, you’re looking at a large motor yacht or the 81-foot sailboat, which takes 50.
Which is faster?
Motor yachts cover distance more quickly, which matters on longer trips across the bay, for example to the Marietas Islands from the south, or to Yelapa from the north side. A sailing catamaran moves at a gentler pace, and when the sails go up, the wind sets the speed.
In practice, the hours you book matter more than the hull. Four hours covers Los Arcos and the central bay, six hours the South Bay beaches, and eight hours a full south-shore day. Pick the departure marina closest to where you want to go, and either kind of yacht will get you there.
What do they cost?
Prices are per yacht, in USD, and most include 10 guests. Here is every catamaran next to a cross-section of the motor yachts:
| Yacht | Type | Guests incl. / max | Shortest charter | Extra guest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lagoon 42 | Sailing catamaran | 10 / 18 | 4 h, $2,090 | $75 |
| Lagoon 40 | Sailing catamaran | 10 / 18 | 4 h, $2,095 | $65 |
| Pajot 47 | Catamaran | 10 / 18 | 4 h, $3,490 | $220 |
| VIP Lagoon 42 | Sailing catamaran | 8 / 20 | 5 h, $3,690 | $235 |
| La Cruz 47 | Sailing catamaran | 10 / 16 | 4 h, $3,890 | $95 |
| Leopard 51 | Power catamaran | 8 / 30 | 3 h, $3,490 | $235 |
| Sea Ray 50 | Express cruiser | 10 / 20 | 4 h, $1,395 | $75 |
| Sea Ray 46 | Express cruiser | 10 / 19 | 4 h, $1,790 | $75 |
| Azimut 59 | Motor yacht | 10 / 25 | 4 h, $2,890 | $95 |
| Hatteras 75 | Motor yacht | 10 / 45 | 4 h, $3,490 | $145 |
| Cheoy Lee 90 | Motor yacht | 10 / 46 | 4 h, $6,195 | $90 |
| Viva 85 | Motor yacht | 10 / 25 | 4 h, $6,795 | $165 |
| Hatteras 122 | Superyacht | 10 / 22 | 4 h, $17,395 | $295 |
The cheapest yachts in the fleet are the Kata 27, an open day boat, at $1,295 for up to 8 guests and the Sea Ray 50, an express cruiser, at $1,395. Catamarans start around $2,090. At the top end, the motor yachts go much higher than any catamaran.
What does that come to per person?
Split across a group, the gap narrows. For 16 guests on a 4-hour charter, including extra-guest fees:
- Sea Ray 50: $1,845 in total, about $115 each.
- Lagoon 42: $2,540 in total, about $159 each.
- Azimut 59: $3,460 in total, about $216 each.
For 24 guests, the Azimut 59 comes to $4,220, about $176 each, and the Hatteras 75 to $5,520, about $230 each. Gratuity for the crew, usually 10 to 20% in cash, is on top. Our guide to tipping has the numbers.
What about food and drink?
It depends on the yacht, not the hull type. The Lagoon 40 and Lagoon 42 include ceviche, chips and guacamole, fruit, cold beer and a bottle each of tequila, rum and vodka. The Pajot 47 and the La Cruz 47 include a private chef and an open bar. The Leopard 51 and the VIP Lagoon 42 come with a premium open bar and a Mediterranean menu.
On the motor yacht side, the Hatteras 75 and the Hatteras 122 include a private chef, and the President 92 grills surf and turf on an open-flame grill. Many of the mid-size motor yachts include ceviche and cold beer, with upgrades available. You can add a chef or a premium open bar to almost any charter; see add-ons.
Which has more on board?
Again, it depends on the yacht. Most catamarans carry snorkel gear, a lily pad and paddleboards. The Pajot 47 adds Starlink Wi-Fi and an electric swim platform that lowers to the water, and the Leopard 51 adds floatie toys.
The larger motor yachts carry the bigger toys. The Don Mois 85 has a jacuzzi and a slide. The President 92 has a jacuzzi, a waterslide, a kayak, a banana boat with a dinghy and a jet ski. If water toys are the main event for your group, check those two first; every yacht page lists exactly what is aboard.
Where do they leave from?
Three of the six catamarans are based in La Cruz, two in Nuevo Vallarta and one in Marina Vallarta. Most of the motor yachts are based in Marina Vallarta, with a few in La Cruz and Nuevo Vallarta. Starting from a yacht’s home marina adds no fee; starting elsewhere adds a relocation fee, listed on each yacht page.
If you’re staying in Sayulita or Bucerías, the La Cruz catamarans are the easiest start. If you’re in town or the hotel zone, Marina Vallarta has the widest choice of motor yachts. The departures guide has the full list by marina.
What about a real sailing yacht?
There is a third option. The Sailboat 81 is a single-hull sailing yacht for up to 50 guests, from $1,795 for 4 hours with 10 included and $90 for each extra guest. It suits big groups who want to sail, and it makes a good sunset charter. Whether the sails go up depends on the wind on the day.
Which is better for a celebration?
For a bachelorette, a birthday or a friends’ trip, most groups choose a catamaran. The wide deck works for dancing and photos, the bow nets are made for lying in the sun, and the lily pad off the stern keeps the swim stop lively. The VIP Lagoon 42 and the Leopard 51 include a premium open bar, which takes care of the drinks.
For a wedding ceremony, a corporate event or a group over 30, a large motor yacht or the Sailboat 81 usually fits better. The Hatteras 75, the Cheoy Lee 90 and the Sailboat 81 take between 45 and 50 guests. For a proposal or an anniversary for two, the Marquis 50 or the Kata 27, a small open day boat, gives you privacy at a lower price.
Who should pick which?
Book a catamaran if you’re a family or mixed-age group, someone worries about motion, you want a long lunch at anchor and lots of swimming, or you want the most space for the money with up to 30 guests.
Book a motor yacht if you want to cover more water, your group is over 30, you want a particular look or feature such as a jacuzzi or a slide, or you’re a small group on a tight budget, where the Sea Ray 50 or the Kata 27 make the most sense.
Still undecided? Compare every luxury catamaran and every signature motor yacht side by side, or message Kyle with your group size and the day you have in mind. The FAQs cover inclusions, deposits and the weather policy.
Three yachts to compare
One of each kind, plus a large-group option. Prices are in USD, per yacht.
-
The value catamaran
Lagoon 42 from $2,090 / 4 hrs
$2,090 for 4 hours with 10 guests included and room for 18, from La Cruz.
-
The value motor boat
Sea Ray 50 from $1,395 / 4 hrs
$1,395 for 4 hours with 10 guests included and room for 20, from Marina Vallarta.
-
For groups up to 45
Hatteras 75 from $3,490 / 4 hrs
$3,490 for 4 hours with a private chef and a premium open bar, from Nuevo Vallarta.
Quick questions
Many guests find a catamaran steadier, because the two hulls sit wide apart. A morning start and staying on deck also help, and bring any medication you use.
No. Whether the sails go up depends on the wind on the day; the captain decides. They run on engines the rest of the time.
Catamarans top out at 30 guests, on the Leopard 51. For bigger groups, the Sailboat 81 takes 50, the Cheoy Lee 90 takes 46 and the Hatteras 75 takes 45.


